Transgenerational “healing”: what it actually means and what therapy can (and cannot) do

Hands holding old family photographs, sharing memories
Illustrative image. Photo: SHVETS production / Pexels · Free Pexels License.

Cristina Schmidt
Psychotherapist, Trainer and Supervisor, Trainer and Coach, Vice-President ITSP.

Transgenerational “healing” is not a healing in the medical sense; it does not mean erasing the family past nor “repairing” the ancestors. It means understanding what has been transmitted to you and consciously choosing how you manage your emotions and behaviour from now on. Your change takes place in the way you think, act, react and work with your emotions.

Why do I put “healing” in quotation marks?

Because it is a medical word, and a transgenerational inheritance is not a disease. The word suggests that there is a “sick” state and one “without traces”, and in therapy you would concentrate on what you know and understand as representing healing: no longer feeling the suffering, no longer having the symptoms and then being as good as new, cleansed of everything that comes from the family past. Yet this creates unrealistic expectations of transgenerational psychotherapy.

“Transgenerational healing” has come to be used so often in discussions, posts and writings about the contents of psychogenealogy that it has become part of the beliefs of those interested in the problems of the family past. And this also leads to unrealistic expectations, the term promising more than it can deliver.

What can change, concretely?

Your family’s story remains your family’s story, and history, the facts cannot be changed.

What can change is the way you relate to them and the place they occupy in your life: from something that influences you without your knowing, both in your feelings and in your reactions and behaviours, to something you live consciously.

That is why I prefer words such as integration, reframing or release. I still use “healing”, because that is how people search online, in general, but with the proper quotation marks, clarifying each time the meaning of the word with those in front of whom I pronounce it.

What can transgenerational psychotherapy do?

  • Put a name to feelings that until then had no story.
  • Separate what is yours from what is theirs. A fear, an anger may be the grandmother’s, even if you feel it too.
  • Make possible a postponed, unfinished mourning. Losses that could not be wept then can be recognised now.
  • Bring the resources to the surface. In the history of a family there are not only wounds, but also people who survived, started over, rebuilt. Like the lady on the train about whom I wrote in What is psychogenealogy.
  • Change the relationship and the way you relate to those before you. Ivan Boszormenyi-Nagy spoke of exoneration: seeing parents and ancestors in their context, without accusing them and without idealising them.

What can therapy not do?

  • It does not change the past. What happened remains what happened.
  • It does not “heal” the ancestors. The work is done with you, for you, in your inner world.
  • It does not offer certainties. The links between past and present are interpretations, not proofs.
  • It does not guarantee results in one session. Sometimes an understanding comes quickly, but integrating it takes time.
  • It does not make predictions. That is, it cannot guarantee that by doing transgenerational therapy you will stop the transmission of traumas.
  • It does not replace medical or psychiatric treatment. In a severe depression or an acute crisis the first step is the doctor.

What does the process look like, briefly?

Each therapist works in his or her own way. Usually the process goes through several stages:

  1. The request. What brings you: a symptom, a repetition, a question about the family.
  2. Exploring the family history. The main instrument is the genosociogram, about which I write in Introduction to Genosociogram.
  3. Identifying the patterns. Repetitions of dates, ages, names, roles and silences.
  4. Emotional work. Dialogue, symbolic exercises, sometimes techniques from psychodrama.
  5. Integration. What you have discovered is linked to your life now and to your choices.
  6. Training. Integrating the things understood into new reactions and behaviours, appropriate to the situations.
  7. Transition. It is the period in which the old reactions overlap with the new models learned through training.
  8. Maintaining the new life model. The period in which you put attention on the new models of life.

In my practice I introduced stages 6, 7 and 8 following the fact that many clients returned to therapy upset or frightened that the symptoms, the reactions had returned, and they were disappointed that they had not changed. This determined me to find solutions for these situations. I will develop them in articles in the coming months and will then add the link that will direct to that information.

What does such a change look like, concretely?

Someone who lives the state of anger, with a justiciary attitude or complaining about irregularities, injustice, is, perhaps, the descendant of a family in which injustices, unfairnesses took place. For example, people who constantly complain about happenings in their life or in others’ in which unfair things happened. Or the person enters into conflict quite often, for important or banal things, saying things like “you are all thieves, you take even the little I have”: at work, in public, shopping, on holiday, wherever there is for her a source of injustice.

It is possible that he or she discovers in his or her genealogy a great injustice, hard to understand and to accept.

Working transgenerationally, he or she may reach the point of understanding the ancestors and then working with the lenses through which he or she sees the world and life situations, adding new lenses through which to see also other parts of the reality in which he or she lives. Further on he or she will actively work on his or her reactions and behaviours, which he or she will train in the direction of ones as appropriate as possible to the situations.

How do you recognise unrealistic promises?

In recent years “transgenerational healing” has also become a product. Some offers are serious, others less so. A few signals that should make you attentive:

  • you are promised the healing of “your entire lineage” in a single session or in a few steps;
  • you are given a “transgenerational diagnosis” without anyone knowing anything about your family;
  • you are told that an illness has a single cause, in the family past, and that you no longer need a doctor;
  • you are asked to break the relationship with the family in order to “free yourself”;
  • the person does not have a basic training in psychotherapy and does not work under supervision.

Working with traumas, whether yours or inherited, requires time, framework and responsibility. It does not need miracles.

How do you choose a transgenerational psychotherapist?

Anne Ancelin Schützenberger drew attention, in Aïe, mes aïeux!, that any client should check the professional profile of the one who declares himself or herself a transgenerational psychotherapist. The name of a training institution says nothing about its quality. Before you start, check:

  • basic training in psychotherapy and the right of free practice in the country where the therapist works: his or her name must appear in the professional register of that country (in Romania, in the register of the College of Psychologists of Romania);
  • specific training in psychogenealogy or transgenerational analysis: where he or she did it, how long it lasted, with whom;
  • supervision: a professional psychotherapist discusses his or her cases with a supervisor;
  • the way he or she describes the process to you: a professional tells you openly what therapy can and cannot do.

One of the missions of the Institute of Transgenerational Studies and Practices, which I founded together with my colleagues, is the establishment of international standards of training in transgenerational psychotherapy. The training we offer includes all the eight stages described above.

Frequently asked questions about transgenerational healing

Can a transgenerational trauma be healed? The way you carry it can change. The past remains the same, but what was lived without words can be understood, wept and integrated, and the patterns lose some of their force.

Can I do this alone? You can start alone: ask, note, find out the family story. Interpretation and emotional work, however, are done better and more safely together with a specialist.

How long does a process of transgenerational therapy last? It depends on the established objective and on the transgenerational problem. A specific question can be clarified in a few sessions, while old and painful patterns may require a few months. And one more thing: rational understanding does not have the same rhythm as emotional understanding.

If I work with myself, do I also help my children? Often, yes. No one can make predictions, but what has been put into words and understood is transmitted further differently from what has remained silent. It is not a guarantee, but it is a real change in the family story.

What comes next?

Everything I have described here starts from a map: the family history laid out on paper, with dates, events and links. In the next article I show you how this map is built, step by step: Introduction to Genosociogram.

And if you feel it is the moment to look more carefully at your own family history, you can find me at contact@psychogenealogy.info.

Sources

  • Ancelin Schützenberger, A. (1988). Aïe, mes aïeux! Paris: Desclée de Brouwer, collection La Méridienne.
  • Boszormenyi-Nagy, I., & Spark, G. M. (1973). Invisible Loyalties: Reciprocity in Intergenerational Family Therapy. Hagerstown, MD: Harper & Row.

About the author: Cristina Schmidt is a transgenerational psychotherapist and founder, together with her colleagues, of the Institute of Transgenerational Studies and Practices. She works with people who want to understand and integrate the patterns inherited from the family and trains psychotherapists in the transgenerational approach. Find out more at psychogenealogy.info.

Published on 1 August